http://mytv.tvb.com/variety/clubsparkle/7062/378#page-1 00:06:18 - 00:12:50 ,
and ABC's "The View" - Susan Boyle,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuNkU3p8Oxc
Comparison between the segment of "The View" and 星星同學會
Front:
In Setting Aspect:
Both talk shows’ studios were set with a plain and casual background. In “The View” talk show, the five hosts were sitting around the table with the title “The View” background. On the other hand, there was no title “星星同學會” shown in the background design and the hosts and guests were sit separately.
In Appearance Aspect:
All hosts and guests in two talk shows were dressing up and having appropriate make-up and hairstyle.
In Manner Aspect:
Both hosts in talk shows were discussing some topics in a casual manner. Sometimes, manner can change according to the situations. In both “The View” and “星星同學會”, all people were talking about some entertainment topics. During the conversation, they were always discussing with belly laugh.
Opening and Closing:
In Opening Aspect:
Different cultures have different ways to begin conversations. For the Hong Kong Talk Show “星星同學會”, the hosts introduced the guests to the audiences while the American Talk Show’s hosts didn’t do it. Both of the talk shows did introduce the topics they would talk about afterwards.
In Closing Aspect:Both shows’ closings were quite different due to different cultures. In the “The View”, hosts just ended the show while the hosts of “星星同學會” showed thank you to their guests and greeted to the audiences for the next week show.
Different cultures have different ways to begin conversations. For the Hong Kong Talk Show “星星同學會”, the hosts introduced the guests to the audiences while the American Talk Show’s hosts didn’t do it. Both of the talk shows did introduce the topics they would talk about afterwards.
In Closing Aspect:Both shows’ closings were quite different due to different cultures. In the “The View”, hosts just ended the show while the hosts of “星星同學會” showed thank you to their guests and greeted to the audiences for the next week show.
Adjacency Pairs:
In “星星同學會”, all answers were followed by the questions the hosts asked. One guest’s sayings basically determined what the next person said. This is the “paired actions” adjacency pairs. There were also some overlaps in the talk show among the guests, however, they would give the turn to others politely.
In “星星同學會”, all answers were followed by the questions the hosts asked. One guest’s sayings basically determined what the next person said. This is the “paired actions” adjacency pairs. There were also some overlaps in the talk show among the guests, however, they would give the turn to others politely.
In the “The View”, the overlapping in the discussion was quite often and complicated. Some of them even dominated the conversation by using louder voice.
沒有留言:
張貼留言